Lawmakers close to deal to eliminate juvenile boot camps
By Brent Kallestad, Associated Press, April 26, 2006
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. --Florida lawmakers agreed Wednesday to shut down the state's juvenile boot camps after the
death of a 14-year-old boy who had been kicked and punched by guards.
The move, agreed to by House and Senate negotiators, is part of a state budget agreement that still requires both
Under the deal, Florida's four remaining boot camps would be replaced with a new, less militaristic program. The
state would pump an additional $32.6 million into juvenile justice programs, increasing total spending to $699.5
"Unfortunately it has taken the death of a young man to get to this point," said Republican Rep. Gus Barreiro,
chairman of the House Juvenile Justice Appropriations Committee.
The move was prompted by the death Jan. 6 of Martin Lee Anderson, who was roughed up in a videotaped scuffle at
a Panama City boot camp. The camp was shut down after the boy's death, which remains under investigation and
has drawn protests from civil rights leaders.
"Now there won't be any more children being abused while in the custody of the state," said attorney Ben Crump,
who is representing Anderson's parents in a lawsuit against the state and the sheriff's office that ran the camp. "It is
something good to have a legacy knowing that his death wasn't in vain."
Florida had nine juvenile boot camps at the height of the program but is now down to four, with about 130 offenders
in all. The teenagers are sent there for mid-level crimes such as burglary and drugs, and usually stay for four to six
Guards operate like drill sergeants, typically waking up the teenagers at 5 a.m. for calisthenics, yelling in their faces,
and using push-ups and running as punishment for breaking the rules.
Gov. Jeb Bush, who had been a strong supporter of the boot camps, has said he supports the new measures, which
would take effect July 1.
The new juvenile programs, like the boot camps, would be run by sheriffs, but they would be closely monitored by the
state. The programs would emphasize self-esteem and prohibit physical intervention between guards and
youngsters. Under the old system, guards were legally allowed to physically intervene for disciplinary purposes.
A medical examiner concluded Anderson died of natural causes -- a blood disorder. But the boy's family and others
disputed that, and the body was exhumed for a second autopsy. The results have not been released, but the office
of a special prosecutor has said Anderson did not die of natural causes.
Rep. Gus Barreiro, a Miami Beach Republican who chaired the House Juvenile Justice Appropriations Committee,
agreed to take the Senate's $10.5 million budget offer for the new programs to his leadership in the morning.
"Juvenile boot camps will no longer exist in this state," said Sen. Rod Smith, D-Alachua, who announced the
proposal. "They will be replaced by other programs - not based on any concept of physical abuse or psychological
intimidation that would be harmful."
Lawmakers focused intensely on boot camps after the death in early January of Martin Lee Anderson, a 14-year-old
Panama City boy who died in a Pensacola hospital only hours after being roughed up by guards at the Bay County
camp which has been subsequently shut down.
"Just to take someone out and yell at them and have them run around a track just isn't going to work," Smith said.
The four existing programs will now be modeled after a highly successful one in Martin County where a three-tiered,
yearlong program boasted the lowest recidivism rate in the state with almost 80 percent of the juveniles who
complete the program staying away from further trouble with the law.
The new concept will be called the STAR program, an acronym for Sheriff's Training and Respect.
Gov. Jeb Bush, who had been a strong supporter of the boot camp concept, also backed the changes, a spokesman
"The governor certainly supports implementing some of the best practices we saw in use in Martin County,"
spokesman Russell Schweiss said. "And this program will do that."
The agreement includes a provision for the Department of Juvenile Justice, which oversees the state's remaining
four juvenile camps, to institute a quality assurance program.
"One more last, last chance," Smith said. "That's where they are."
However, DJJ chief of staff Chris Caballero was confident the agency could live up to lawmakers expectations.
"The sheriff's are committed," Caballero said. "We had a death of a child that's in your care and there's no way to
candycoat that. We have to address it, stand up by it and do the right thing."
Barreiro, who has largely been the legislative face on the changes, was confident better times lay ahead.
"It puts kids in the right posture for success and for their safety," he said.